Project Grading

Cryptography and Computer Network Security

Up

Specification: 5 points

  1. completness (based on the guidelines) - 3 points
  2. clearity of main project goals - 2 points

Presentation: 10 points

  1. sufficient background - 1 point
  2. clear presentation of main results - 2 points
  3. conclusions - 1 points
  4. logical organization of the talk - 1 point
  5. quality of slides - 1 point
  6. discussion of the encountered problems - 1 point
  7. handling questions - 3 points

Results - software and hardware projects: 12 points

  1. Working implementation - 2 points
  2. Testing scheme - 1 point
  3. Performance (speed, memory, area) - 2 points
  4. Analysis of the results - 1 point
  5. Difficulty of obtaining the presented results - 3 points
  6. Agreement of results with the original specification - 2 points
  7. Possibility of practical application of the obtained results - 1 point

Results - analytical projects: 12 points

  1. Correctness of the analysis - 3 points
  2. Quality of the solution (security, performance) - 2 points
  3. Originality of the solution - 1 point
  4. Difficulty of obtaining the presented results - 3 points
  5. Agreement of results with the original specification - 2 points
  6. Possibility of practical application of the obtained results - 1 point

Documentation: 8 points

  1. Introduction - 1 point
  2. Description of main results - 2 points
  3. Figures and tables - 1.5 point
  4. Conclusions - 1 point
  5. Proper references - 0.5 point in software and hardware projects; 1.5 point in analytical projects
  6. Proper organization - 1 point
  7. Documentation of the source code (C, VHDL, configuration files) - 1 point in software and hardware projects)